Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Caraglio's Pizza
Welcome to Caraglio's Pizza, a hidden gem located at 3869 Lyell Rd, Rochester, NY! If you're on the lookout for a delightful dining experience that brings the essence of quality pizza to your table, this is the place to visit. Renowned for its remarkable dough, Caraglio's Pizza has quickly gained a reputation that echoes through the community. As noted by enthusiastic patrons like Shadow King, the quality of their crust reflects an artistry reminiscent of the beloved bakeries from the 80s and 90s, a nostalgic nod to the past that resonates beautifully with lovers of authentic flavors.
Not only is the pizza at Caraglio's crafted with precision and care, but it is also offered at a price point that caters to budgets of all kinds. Customers often mention their specials, making it easier for families to enjoy a night out without breaking the bank. Dominic Miller relays a point about the slicing, a minor detail that highlights the love for pizza and the suggestions that come with it — a testament to their commitment to improvement. While we crave the hearty flavors of their well-prepared pizza, the customer feedback encourages a closer look at the overall experience, which remains overwhelmingly positive.
Maggie Aubeuf praises Caraglio's, especially for UFC nights, where their quick delivery and consistent warmth set them apart. The extensive menu – which extends beyond pizza to include grilled items like burgers and chicken – ensures there’s something for everyone. This versatility makes Caraglio's an ideal choice for family gatherings or casual get-togethers.
As for the quality of the pizza, reminiscent of a warm embrace from your favorite childhood meal, customers rave about its freshness and richness. Possum W.'s delight in their speedy service and the sheer joy of biting into a slice that balances flavors perfectly encapsulates the essence of Caraglio's Pizza. It’s a place where every visit can lead to another blissful culinary revelation.
Caraglio's Pizza isn't just about the food; it's about community, character, and care. The accommodating staff and inviting atmosphere create a welcoming environment for first-timers like MaryLouise Brennan, who walked away thoroughly satisfied after her initial meal. With eager patrons anticipating their return, it's clear that Caraglio's Pizza is a pinnacle of delightful dining in Rochester. Whether you find yourself craving a slice after a long day or planning a fun night in, Caraglio's Pizza is sure to deliver an experience as memorable as the flavors on your plate. So why wait? Dive into the delectable world of Caraglio's and experience it for yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is a true diamond in the rough! The quality of the dough alone is remarkable! Easily upper tier quality reminds me of the bakeries on the NW side in the 80s and 90s. They then create delicious pizza that is very reasonably priced. I find their specials very helpful to me who observes a moderate budget. A well earned 5 stars. ”
“ Love there pizza the single slices could be a little bigger. Also if your out off pepperoni don't fake a new slice just be honest. ”
“ We love this place!! The pizza is so good THE BEST in Gates. The delivery is always super quick and food never gets delivered cold. We always pick Caraglio's for UFC nights, would 10/10 recommend this place. They also offer grilled items such as burgers, grilled chicken, etc! The menu is extensive enough to find something for everyone in the family. Thanks Caraglio's for great service and great pizza! ”
“ My boyfriend and I were trying to find a quick place to eat he waited for the food for about 5 min, 20 mins shorter than another pizza place I had been to. And don't get me a starter on the pizza I have never had pizza that good it tasted fresh, warm, and so good. I want to give a big old kiss to whoever made that pizza(also give that person a raise )10/10 will be back for more :) ”
“ I ordered my first ever Pizza from Caraglio's on Lyell Road for take out yesterday. It was delicious and the people who work there are so nice! I will definitely be ordering from there again! ”
“ I have been going to Caraglio's Pizza in Gates for many years. It was recommended to me by a pizza 'connoisseur'. I only go on Mondays or Tuesdays, the 'All Day Special'. On those days, one can get a large cheese pizza for 12.99 plus tax. Extra toppings are 2.00. Occasionally I will get chicken wings. I have Never had a bad pizza from Caraglio's. Their chicken wings are good too. I call ahead of time and pick up my pizza. Caraglio's Pizza also has an app where one can accure points after each pizza purchase. After so many points built up, a person can get free bread sticks, free mozzarella sticks, free medium cheese pizza, free boneless chicken wings, and a free one topping pizza. I have Never had a problem with the cashier, or the person on the phone taking my order. Kudos to Caraglio's Pizza! ”
“ The best pizza and value in Rochester. Always greeted by positive helpful employees. My kids and I refuse to go anywhere else. Couldn’t ask for better food and customer service. Thankful to have such friendly familiar staff each visit ”
“ Pizza was nice and chewy the way I like my pizza. The pepperoni used was cup and char, also my favorite. Just enough sauce. Not over done. Good stuff, I will surely go back. They do offer a great mon, tue pizza deal I want to try. The chicken tenders were nice and tender not rock hard. Lots of parking ,eat in or take out. ”